Tuesday, November 06, 2012

Sockeye Salmon & Bison

In reading the Vancouver Sun editorial about the Cohen report dealing with the uncertain future of wild salmon on the BC coast, I could not help but think of parallels in our national experience with bison -- in particular, the so-called disappearance of the bison from the plains of North America.

To me, the parallels are striking.  In the case of salmon, the word 'decline' has been substituted for the word 'disappearance', the latter of which was for years associated with the almost-complete annihilation of the bison.

We now acknowledge that the elimination of the bison was in large part the result of systematic, quasi-industrial killing efforts, erasing the wild order and replacing it with cattle & grain production, railroads, residential communities and fences.  This is not to mention explicit public policy efforts to starve First Nations populations onto reserves.

Over the intervening years, with regard to the uncertain future of wild salmon, our society has learned to be somewhat more subtle in its approach to the destruction of the wild.  But not a lot different.  Me-first competition among the various fishing interests, introduction of competing but artificial aquaculture, habitat destruction through urban and commercial development, all look to me a lot like what happened to the bison.  We even have rough parallels with regard to the economic and social effects on First Nations of our area.

Perhaps this ongoing assault on the wild is inevitable.  But we ought not to pretend that we are mystified by what is happening.